I got the mellow brown, and this brown is so natural and when you smudge it before it dries it creates this hazy look. Once the eyeliner dries, it won't budge at all, no amount of water or rubbing can smudge this and the eyeliner goes one smoothly without clumps. One tip though is to be careful opening the eyeliner. I was too excited, opened the cap and about 0.25 cm of it broke off. Even though it broke off, there were still enough to last me about 2 months.