This eyeliner is very long lasting and its quite waterproof, unless you are rubbing harshly it will stay on the entire day. I ordered one in Cinnamon Toast, I love the colour and the shimmer particles. I can't say for sure about the other colours, but this pencil is quite dry and not very creamy at all, it tugs on my eyelids a lot. This is the only downside, I wonder if the other pencils without chunky glitters are a bit smoother and creamier. Overall this is a great colour for contouring the outside corners of the eyes, it also stays for a long time but due to its consistency it does tend to tug on the eyelids.