To start with, I must say that I thought that this was an auto liner kind of pencil (my bad here), so when I discover it wasn't I was a little bummed, specially because I suck at sharpening eyeliner pencils and end up breaking the tip. But leaving that behind, It's a really nice eyeliner. It has a really soft texture while applying it and it doesn't dry so quickly that you have no time to smudge or correct the line. Once it dries up, it's seriously waterproof with no transfer at all. Last, the shade is to die for! All in all, I really like this eyeliner but still wish it would come in auto liner kind of version.