I got the shade #2 Deep Brown and it's a great match for my eyebrows. It doesn't get clumpy, on the contrary, it shows a delicate color on the spaces where my eyebrows are not abundant. I have to pass it like 4 or 5 times to get the desired color but I rather like that then getting too much color in just one pass. The little brush it has comes very handy when you are done getting the color, so you can fiz the shape of your eyebrows.