I love this cushion, the case and puff are soooo cute. Also, the 23 tone matches my skin pretty well, so I think I will be purchasing more refills for this case. It doesn't get cakey but you have to moisturize your face first, so the cakey look doesn't appear after a few hours. I think this is quite the steal for the price, since it comes with a refill. The case is just the same as the Air Fit XP pink cushion, so no rpoblem when trying to buy a refill.