First I order the strawberry version that liked it very much, every time I use it I have a babyface that has never before. So this is why I ordered and I have to try the black sugar version. It has a little bit citrus scent. The consistence is harder than the other one, so be aware not to scrub it so hard. Sometimes I use it like a face-pack and let it on my face 5-10 minutes, my skin is very grateful for it. The package is better than the other one, I think they improve it. Because inside there is a cap as well, which is not let to leak the product. I like it very much but if I have to decide which one prefer than the strawberry one win!