I have to be honest. I bought these because I thought it would be a good dupe for EL's Double Wear Foundation. It isn't. They are similar in consistency but not in pigmentation. It's a touch more sheer. It also transfer. On a positive note however, I actually like that it's a bit on the light weight division, as it is less cakey (beware of layering). It wears off around the 9 hour mark, but hey, that's healthy, right? It doesn't break me out, and it gives decent coverage. So four stars, because it's affordable and it's good as itself even if it isn't a great dupe. :)