I bought #1 Black and #10 Peach. I haven't tried the black one all day so I can't attest to its longevity, but it doesn't tug on the skin and it's fairly easy to do eye makeup with. Although when I try sharpening it sometimes, the liner crumbles and breaks into pieces. With the peach liner, I use it regularly for my under eye. It's an easy way to add a bit of sparkle without being too glittery. I took a star off because of the fragility of the black liner, but I recommend the peach one if you want to try under eye makeup.