I tried so many cleansing oil before (banila co, heimish, the face shop, etc...), I like this one right now the most. It is a heavier one and it moisturize my skin well. It cleans my face and my makeup very well. Easy to use it. I like to massage my face with it. The smell is really good. I haven't tried the other type yet, but this is good for now. This is the 2nd time I buy this so it seems my face like it as well. I give you 5 star because I like the way it works.