I purchased the shade vanilla sugar, and I'm not too impressed. First of all, to be fair the product, I wanted a matte white eyeliner, but it didn't promise to be matte, so I can't really get upset about that. However! This shimmery white liner does not last long. It is the type of product where I could apply it and easily have it wear off. I found it to be not very pigmented. I think there are better liners out there.