4.5 stars, I recently got number 3, Orange Scene and I have to say that I really like the color. At first, I was afraid because it was my very first tie trying and orange color, but this one has a little bit of red, and to me, it's more wearable because of that. I like the smell too, a bit peculiar, but like it. Also, it has like a jelly consistency

The things I wasn't so pleased about, it's that it can be drying and look weird when your lips are drying by its own, like it happens to me some times. Maybe I will get another color in the near future! :)