I've been using this for a while now, every day. Doesn't at all smudge, beautiful colors (I just rebought the all black one, maybe would be adventurous enough to try the crazier colors in the future? :D). Love the little under eye wand but the brown color is too light to notice so I didn't bother with it too much. It stays put all day, which isn't easy with my eyes. In fact, you need some strong oil or cream remover to clean this big boy. Which means high points for me! The wand does tend to form gunk but that's the least I worry about.